RadioSilence

  • Beitritt 3. Juni 2022
  • 0 Gefolgte Mitglieder1 Mitglieder folgen mir
  • Profil

  • 69633 Punkte
  • "We tell ourselves stories in order to live." – Joan Didion

  • RadioSilence

    thank you so much! so glad you liked it :")

    1. no! actually the first title for the book was “by the time you read this i’ll be dead” which kind of sets the tone for how the book was going to be. it was a very grim book in the first drafts, and while the ending was supposed to be open-ended, with the reader deciding whether they survived the boat or not, a lot of my early readers thought they didn’t make it. coupled with how hopeless the book was, my agent advised me to add more hope in it. and when i did, i could see how it elevated the pain that it already had. the sweet moments that could be taken away at any time. i realized that ending it on a sad note would have been somewhat unfair to the revolution. they’re doing all of this because of hope. hope for a good ending. it’s just like that line in catching fire “the only thing stronger than fear is hope”
    2. yep, i did. every author goes through that. and you go through it with every book you write. i am still looking for the cure for it 😂 juggling so much in one’s life can leave no room for writing. in the end, we write because we love it. i think that’s the beauty of this profession. it’s the only one in the world that we do because we do love it.
  • As I’m currently on holiday I couldn’t find many times to come on here and discuss the sections as frequently as I would have liked.

    But I don’t want to miss this last chance of sharing my thoughts on the novel.

    I am very, very thankful that I got to read it. So firstly, thanks to Orell Füssli for gifting us this book. Secondly, thanks to Zoulfa Katouh for putting this thought-provoking, tough and bittersweet story out there. It seems wrong to say that I enjoyed to read it, as the main theme is so dark and horrible, but Zoulfa does a very good job weaving in hopeful and lighter moments. It’s this combination that makes us root for all the people we meet - even Am.

    On the whole, the characters are all written with so much depth. Not just the main ones but also Dr. Ziad and Nour for example. Their actions in these horrific circumstances seemed all very authentic and it was very easy to empathise with them.

    There were a few moments that broke my heart (the bombing of the hospital for example), but I do share the thoughts with many other readers that the revelation of Layla’s situation was absolutely gut-wrenching - and yet also made so much sense. Layla and Khawf both were such powerful storydrivers! Khawf symbolising fear in Salama’s life and Layla countering this with her embodying hope. Wonderfully written!

    Though the love story threw me off a bit at the beginning, I was glad that it was there in the end, as it lifted some of the heaviness of the setting and also made me swoon here and there. Kenan is such a lovely young man!

    I’m ashamed to admit that I don’t know much about the Syrian war, but it made me think a lot, and I do plan on informing myself more on this.

    For my question for Zoulfa I’d piggy back on MDSOMA ‘s question. I’d love to know the intention behind the epilogue.

    In my opinion, it’s good that there is one. As much as I’m a fan of open endings, this story, though spiked with hopeful glimpses here and there, was in need of some light. I’m glad that we got to see a sliver of what Salama’s and Kenan’s life looked after the horrific experiences.

    A second question would be how long it took Zoulfa to write the book. As this is a very mentally challanging story, I’d guess that it wasn’t written in a week. How did you deal with the emotions that came up while writing this novel?

    Thanks again to Zoulfa and Orell Füssli!

    • I almost forgot to write something about it because of all the emotion. First I had to go back to see where part two went so as not to spoil it. The story really grabbed me.

      About part two: This one is not less emotional than the one before, reading in public is still not possible. But unlike part two, it’s now happy emotions with Salama and Kenan. Their love in all the suffering is a glimmer of hope.

      Over this story I keep catching myself thinking “it’s not just a story, in Syria a big part of this book is real.” Which, in between, keeps me thinking and sad, and at the same time grateful for everything I have.

    • RadioSilence
      I absolutely hear you. I hope my comment didn’t come across as an attack on your take. Because that’s not at all what I inteded to do. I just wanted to give my point of view on Khawf. I do not mind that you see him and his representation a little different than me, in fact, I think that this is one of the most enjoyable things while reading in a group. You discuss and talk about the story and are therefore able to view it from different angles, as different people have different opinions and things that stand out to them 😊

    • RadioSilence

      I’m finally caught up on the first part too and I share most of the thoughts and feelings of you all.

      It feels wrong to say that I love this story so far, as it depicts such horrors and difficult situations with the war being the one big thing that drives thoughts, words and actions of our characters.

      I love the writing style and really enjoy diving deeper into Salama’s mind. Khawf, to me, seems like an accurate representation of what trauma and guilt can look like for someone.

      Not to compare her suffering and trauma with mine (as I’ve never had to experience war), but I do believe that his aggressivnes is not over the top, because I know the cruel things I hear in my own head - with trauma that hasn’t even got guilt in it, or war as a setting - so I do believe that Khawf’s part is very authentic.

      I hope that we see Salama silence him more and more as the story progresses, and all in all, I’m very much intrigued to read on.

      • RadioSilence “The Island of Missing Trees” kann ich sehr empfehlen. Ich habe das Buch in Englisch gelesen und sehr gern gehabt. Viel Vergnügen beim lesen🙂

      • Viele Dinge bewahren dieses Buch davor, durch und durch deprimierend zu sein. Zum einen ist es nie morbide. Ein lebendiger Humor tanzt durch die Seiten, und der Reichtum der Beschreibungen sowie der Reichtum der Herzen der Charaktere können nicht anders, als einen zu erheben. Außerdem ist es schön, eine so ausgewogene Geschichte zu lesen, in der die einfachen Deutschen - selbst die blonden und blauäugigen - genauso in Gefahr sind, ihr Leben zu verlieren, verfolgt zu werden, wie die Juden selbst.

        Ich kann nicht weiter gehen, ohne über den Text selbst zu sprechen. Schon auf der ersten Titelseite weiß man, dass man es mit etwas ganz Besonderem zu tun hat. Die einzige Möglichkeit, Ihnen wirklich zu zeigen, was ich meine, ist, das Buch selbst zu lesen

      • Vielen Dank für alle weiteren Meinungen. Die Schere geht weit auseinander und ihr legt eure jeweilige Meinung schlüssig dar, das finde ich enorm spannend.

        Das Zitat schulde ich euch noch - es kommt aber. Stattdessen hätte ich hier einen Beitrag von SWR2 zum Buch. Ein bisschen Ana Iris Simón für die Ohren.

        Und dann starten wir, so ihr fit seid, heute in den dritten und letzten Leseabschnitt, S. 187-251.

        Hoffentlich viel Spass beim Lesen und bis Freitag.

      • Ein unendlich langer Sommer…
        Ich bin anscheinend die Einzige, die das Buch eher langweilig findet. Ich musste nachschauen, ob es sich eventuell um einen Jugendroman handelt. Dazu würde die Story dieser nagelkauenden ‘Teenager’, die sich im Urlaub verlieben, sehr gut passen. Locker-leicht passt zum Sommer, ja! Aber für mich ist die Handlung zu sehr klischiert und vorhersehbar. Zudem stolpere regelmässig über holprige oder schräge Sätze wie: ‘Gustav, der nicht gerade ein Zuckerstück war. Anscheinend konnte niemand hier ihn wirklich leiden.’ (S. 110, Mitte) Oder: ‘Und später noch Kniffel!’ rief James,…‘Gustav hatte keine Lust auf Spiele und brummelte nur.’ (S.179, Zeile 4-6).
        Ich kämpfe mich nun noch durch die letzten Seiten und hoffe sehr auf einen versöhnlichen Schluss…

        • Ja, das ist wirklich ein ganz starkes, eindrückliches und berührendes Buch. Und Deine Rezension erinnert mich daran, dass ich es unbedingt mal wieder lesen muss! Alles Gute für die Prüfung!

        • ** 4.25 stars **

          I was sooo excited to get to read this with my buddy read partner, as we both enjoyed this series so far.
          It hit off so well, I was sucked back into the world of Pip Fitz-Amobi and I was very curious to find out what case she would have to solve in this third and final book. We knew from reading the blurb that it will be much, much more personal than the other two.

          It’s also a lot darker while most of the themes and subjects were quite similar to the first two books, but this one went a bit further.
          The first part was quite fast paced and engrossing. We follow Pip in her day to day life after the traumatic events from book no. 2, how she’s dealing with it (or not ), and then there’s these mysterious messages and occurrences that sent Pip’s and my theories flying.

          Safe to say I REALLY enjoyed part one. Not just because of the darker tones and the more mature Pip but also because there’s so many links to the first two cases that tied everything together so nicely.
          Also, towards the end of part one there’s already two situations/happenings that had me shocked! The twist there was placed very well and I was so hooked.

          Unfortunately, part two couldn’t keep up with part one. I enjoyed grappling with difficult moral questions and I also liked the way the author described what happened and what had to be done, it was just a bit too long-winded for me.
          The biggest thing I struggled with though, was that Pip’s actions weren’t challenged and that there were not many reflections. As I don’t want to spoiler anything this might sound a bit strange but I was just a bit disappointed. I somehow lost my connection to most of the characters as their development didn’t feel authentic to me which is just so sad, as the rest of the story was a hit.

          I thought this would be one of my highlights for 2021 but the ending just didn’t do it for me. It’s still a good book (and I’m glad that I’ve read this series) but it’s no 5 star book for me unfortunately.